1st shot doesn't really have a subject. Frame the surfer better if that's what you're going for. Better lense or get closer? Just seems a lot of background 'noise'. It's hard to get a good shot from that angle but you've got a goofy footer's face on a cutty so nice. I'd be wanting to see the texture of the wave face in shots like this, it's hard to make out the shoulder of the wave in this pic. It doesn't make me mind surf essentially. How much does this make me though.

Sorry if I'm being too critical, just my unexpert opinion.
The timing of your shots is v good though so you are obviously a surfer. And the other 3 shots do have good subjects. Although if I was being overly critical, which I am... Shot 2 I'd want from a tad higher view. Get more space between the waves and some more space between the wave and trees. And some more sunlight, and slightly less 50/50 proportions. 3rd shot gets great light through the spray of the turn. Maybe get closer again to the subject, but you've captured the wave well. Even though it's not a very pretty wave. Could also try getting more light on the surfers face? Excellent timing on the move though. Can't really comment on the last one other than it would have been nice to get better light on him. Bit of luck involved in that one though.
Like I say, I'm no expert so maybe the pro shooters can comment. But things I try to remember are: subject, light/framing/angle, straight horizon/good proportions, the right camera settings!

timing. (I'll probably want to add more to that later

) I also read in a mag somewhere that capturing the light through the wave is a winner. And it is, as demonstrated by your shot of the spray and the bottle the winner in holding.
Written too much as usualy, sorry if I offended. It's just your normal MSWmember commenting on something they know very little about. Feel free to ask me about air 360s and the best board for riding Pipe.
